A $7.8 Million Verdict and the Scan You Didn’t Fully Read

A Portland jury has awarded $7.8 million over a lung tumor missed on two breast MRIs, and the question it raises belongs in every dental practice that takes CBCT scans: who is responsible for everything else in the image?
What happened…
Wendi Lui, 51, died in 2023 after a growing lung tumor went unnoticed on two consecutive breast MRI exams at Legacy Good Samaritan Medical Center in Portland, Oregon. She had begun screening in 2018 because of dense breast tissue and a family history of breast cancer.
The scans were aimed at the breast, but they also pulled in part of the lungs. The family’s attorneys say a roughly one-centimeter mass was visible in 2018 and never reported. By her 2019 exam it had reportedly grown to about two centimeters and was missed again. A third exam in 2020 finally triggered a workup, and by then she had non-small cell lung cancer in four lymph nodes. After years of treatment, she died.
In November 2026, a jury awarded her family $7.8 million following an 11-day malpractice trial.
The defense, and the debate…
The suit centered on radiologist Dr. Kari Thomas, who read the 2019 exam. She testified that she looked at the area and judged it to be an imaging artifact, not a true lung abnormality. Breast MRI is built to evaluate breast tissue, and lung findings can be hard to tell apart from technical distortion. Jurors still found her negligent and concluded the miss contributed to Ms. Lui’s death. Her husband, psychiatrist Dr. Gene Lui, reportedly turned down confidential settlements because he wanted the circumstances examined in public.
Clinicians are divided on what the case means. Some physicians argue that a lung mass that keeps growing should have drawn attention no matter why the exam was ordered. Some radiologists counter that hindsight makes findings look obvious that were truly ambiguous in the moment. A missed diagnosis is not automatically negligence, and a verdict cannot settle every clinical question. The standard of care turns on the original images, the technical limits and expert testimony.
Why dentists should care…
The nearest dental parallel is CBCT. A scan ordered for an implant site, an impacted third molar or an endodontic problem can also capture the maxillary sinuses, nasal cavity, airway, cervical spine and other structures. Panoramic radiographs can show surprises too: suspicious radiolucencies, radiopacities and possible carotid artery calcifications.
The American Academy of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology recommends interpreting the entire acquired CBCT volume in a systematic way, and bringing in a suitably trained radiologist when a finding goes beyond the treating dentist’s expertise.
An example from the chair…
Say you are planning an implant in the posterior maxilla. The CBCT shows plenty of bone, but an unexpected abnormality appears in just one sinus. Your implant measurements can be perfect and the exam is still incomplete if that finding is never evaluated.
Whether it needs more workup depends on how it looks on imaging, the patient’s history and any symptoms. Documentation, a clear conversation with the patient and a referral when warranted are all part of the diagnostic process. A referral noted in the chart protects you very little if the patient never grasped the recommendation or nobody tracks whether it happened.
Where AI fits…
Artificial intelligence may someday get better at spotting incidental findings, but catching more abnormalities does not guarantee better outcomes. A tool that flags every doubtful sinus opacity or vascular calcification could drive up extra imaging, referrals, patient anxiety and cost.
We need AI needs to show higher diagnostic accuracy and sensible follow-up without burying dentists in false positives. The clinical decision still belongs to the licensed dentist treating the patient.
A workable imaging workflow…
The takeaway is consistency. Build a routine that every scan goes through:
- Review the full field of view, not just the treatment site.
- Compare against earlier images when you have them.
- Document what you find, including incidental findings.
- Get a specialist read when a finding is outside your expertise.
- Tell the patient clearly what you recommend and confirm they understood.
- Make sure someone owns the follow-up.
Don’t order extra imaging just to protect yourself from lawsuits, but never brush off a suspicious finding because it sits outside the original treatment goal. Every practice should decide who interprets the images, who tells the patient about unexpected findings, and who follows up when more evaluation is recommended.
Who is responsible for reviewing the entire CBCT scan in your practice?
Sources
- The Oregonian/OregonLive: Grieving Family Awarded $7.8 Million After Doctors Failed to Diagnose Woman’s Cancer Two Years in a Row
- AuntMinnie: Jury Awards $7.8 Million After Lung Mass Missed on Breast MRI
- American Academy of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology
- American Dental Association: Dental Radiographic Examinations
- U.S. FDA: Artificial Intelligence-Enabled Medical Devices